Saturday night my wife and I went to dinner at my high school for my fifteenth reunion. There were not too many of my former classmates there but we had a lovely time catching up with a few of them. Most haven't changed too much, the serious are still serious, the nerds still nerdy (but perhaps funnier about it), and the clowns still funny.
My wife asked me how people would have described me in high school. I said probably sarcastic, maybe a little mean. But I don't really know. I was surprised several year ago by a friend who met someone from my high school class telling me that according to my former classmate I was "nice" and "friends with everyone." I don't know if this is a true perception or if classmate didn't want to be totally candid. But it made me wonder if we ever have any idea of what others truly think of us.
Before we left for home we had to search out the ladies' room and I found myself standing in the hallway looking at the bulletin boards for several student organizations. I lingered over the board for the gay-straight alliance. In high school I was never a part of this club (or others, frankly, sports kept me more than busy enough) despite several of my friends belonging to it and trying to get me to join. The fact is I was scared of the truth. I knew, in spite of every attempt to convince myself of the contrary, that I was gay. I knew it and I hated it. I never wanted anyone else to know and I desperately wanted someone else to know. Joining that club would have been like an admission that what so many people assumed about me was true. I wasn't ready for that.
Maybe I didn't know what other people would have said about me but I would have been certain that many of them assumed I was gay (hooray, they were right!). I spent four years trying to hide it. I tried to hide from friends, teammates, roommates, anyone really. I tried to hide it from myself, tried to convince myself that the feelings I had were "normal" and didn't mean anything. The conflicting, twisted braid of feelings about never wanting any one to know the secret and wishing that even just one of them would see me for who I was.
Much of that high school time is spent trying to sort out who you are and when you have to sort part of that out in the dark, like fumbling in the dark room developing negatives, your hands grasping and trying to get everything fed in just right and knowing that if you open the door, or turn on the light too soon, that you will have blown it. Everything will just disappear, and all anyone will see is a blank. All nuance to who you are, obliterated by revealing your secret too soon, or in the wrong way. Instead of the contours and shapes and light and shadow of the full picture of who you are, all that is left is one thing. All that people see is the gay and they forget about the funny, or kind, or athletic, or artistic, or gentle parts of who you are. You are reduced to one simple fact and some people never see more.
It was this fear that kept me from turning on the light. I kept that part of me locked up, in that little bag you use to thread the negatives into the developer thing-ama-bob. So, standing there, staring at the bulletin board for the group I refused to join, while waiting for my wife to come out of the bathroom I smiled to myself. At fifteen or sixteen or eighteen I was just not ready. I was scared that all the work I had done to be me would be wiped out by one admission. Fifteen years later, I know that's not the case. Certainly not for the friends I had in high school (or after). Maybe they wouldn't have been the same to me back then. Fifteen years is a long time.
I often find myself not feeling like high school is that far away. But this weekend, I felt that distance. Not just because I have kids, not just because I am married, and not just because I write for the gayest website around. I understand the person I was then, and I feel for her. I can still slip back into her shoes, feel her pain and longing and loneliness. Fifteen years isn't long enough to erase my connection to that girl, to make it impossible for me to not just remember but to experience those feelings again. But fifteen years is long enough to realize that turning on the light isn't any scarier than living in the dark.